suunto stinger vs. uwatec aladin pro

"Mario" <mandm@flashnet.it> wrote in message
news:9ae829af.0405050713.11b7421b@posting.google.c om...

Mario, I assume you're from Italy. Are you looking for a conservative or liberal computer?
Have you considered the Italian made Dacor Darwin or Mares M1? Or the Cressi-sub Archimede
made in Japan. They're also reviewed on that Rodale's site.


http://www.scubadiving.com/article/0...X19-15,00.html

Adam

"Mario" <mandm@flashnet.it> wrote in message
news:9ae829af.0405050713.11b7421b@posting.google.c om...

Mario, I assume you're from Italy. Are you looking for a conservative or liberal computer?
Have you considered the Italian made Dacor Darwin or Mares M1? Or the Cressi-sub Archimede
made in Japan. They're also reviewed on that Rodale's site.


http://www.scubadiving.com/article/0...X19-15,00.html

Adam

Hello,

Can you please share your comments on how the algorithm of the SUUNTO
STINGER differs from the UWATEC ALADIN PRO and

I mean according to the 1st dive and following repetitive dives, how
much does it differs the allowed diving time ?

Please share your comments adn experiences.

I heard the SUUNTO STINGER is much less permisive than the UWATEC on
the repetitive dives.

Please feel free to include comparisson to any other Dive Computers.

Can you give specific comparisson examples of same dive profiles using
both computers what is the allowed time.

Thanks,

Mario

"Mario" <mandm@flashnet.it> wrote in message
news:9ae829af.0405030206.7f0c2495@posting.google.c om...
> Hello,
>
> Can you please share your comments on how the algorithm of the SUUNTO
> STINGER differs from the UWATEC ALADIN PRO and
>
> I mean according to the 1st dive and following repetitive dives, how
> much does it differs the allowed diving time ?
>
> Please share your comments adn experiences.
>
> I heard the SUUNTO STINGER is much less permisive than the UWATEC on
> the repetitive dives.
>
> Please feel free to include comparisson to any other Dive Computers.
>
> Can you give specific comparisson examples of same dive profiles using
> both computers what is the allowed time.
>
> Thanks,
>
> Mario

There is a comparison study of computers in Jan Feb 2003 Rodale's.

on first dive the Uwatec was more conservative, but on 2nd and 3rd repetitive dive the
Suunto was the more conservative. All computers were set to their most liberal settings.
The Suunto and Uwatec were relatively close but the Pelagics were noticably more liberal
for all three dives.

Adam

"Mario" <mandm@flashnet.it> wrote in message
news:9ae829af.0405030206.7f0c2495@posting.google.c om...
> Hello,
>
> Can you please share your comments on how the algorithm of the SUUNTO
> STINGER differs from the UWATEC ALADIN PRO and
>
> I mean according to the 1st dive and following repetitive dives, how
> much does it differs the allowed diving time ?
>
> Please share your comments adn experiences.
>
> I heard the SUUNTO STINGER is much less permisive than the UWATEC on
> the repetitive dives.
>
> Please feel free to include comparisson to any other Dive Computers.
>
> Can you give specific comparisson examples of same dive profiles using
> both computers what is the allowed time.
>
> Thanks,
>
> Mario

here are some reviews of Aladin Pro. The algorithms of Uwatec and Suunto appear to yield
results that are close that other factors should probably be used to decide which to buy.

Adam

Thanks a lot for your posting,

Is there online a the results of:

> There is a comparison study of computers in Jan Feb 2003 Rodale's.

Is it published online? else how can I get a copy of these results?

Thanks,

Mario

> > Hello,
> >
> > Can you please share your comments on how the algorithm of the SUUNTO
> > STINGER differs from the UWATEC ALADIN PRO and
> >
> > I mean according to the 1st dive and following repetitive dives, how
> > much does it differs the allowed diving time ?
> >
> > Please share your comments adn experiences.
> >
> > I heard the SUUNTO STINGER is much less permisive than the UWATEC on
> > the repetitive dives.
> >
> > Please feel free to include comparisson to any other Dive Computers.
> >
> > Can you give specific comparisson examples of same dive profiles using
> > both computers what is the allowed time.
> >
> > Thanks,
> >
> > Mario
>
> There is a comparison study of computers in Jan Feb 2003 Rodale's.
>
> on first dive the Uwatec was more conservative, but on 2nd and 3rd repetitive dive the
> Suunto was the more conservative. All computers were set to their most liberal settings.
> The Suunto and Uwatec were relatively close but the Pelagics were noticably more liberal
> for all three dives.
>
> Adam

"Mario" <mandm@flashnet.it> wrote in message
news:9ae829af.0405040613.4d7b9d9b@posting.google.c om...
> Thanks a lot for your posting,
>
> Is there online a the results of:
>
> > There is a comparison study of computers in Jan Feb 2003 Rodale's.
>
> Is it published online? else how can I get a copy of these results?
>
> Thanks,
>
> Mario
>

Can you check www.scubadiving.com under dive computers to see if it's there, if not I can
try to scan the pages and send them.

Adam

I found some computers info, but no where I found any comparisson
between suunto stinger and aladin, it will be very kind if you send me
a scanned copy.

Thanks,

MArio

> > Thanks a lot for your posting,
> >
> > Is there online a the results of:
> >
> > > There is a comparison study of computers in Jan Feb 2003 Rodale's.
> >
> > Is it published online? else how can I get a copy of these results?
> >
> > Thanks,
> >
> > Mario
> >
>
> Can you check www.scubadiving.com under dive computers to see if it's there, if not I can
> try to scan the pages and send them.
>
> Adam

"Mario" <mandm@flashnet.it> wrote in message
news:9ae829af.0405050713.11b7421b@posting.google.c om...

Mario, I assume you're from Italy. Are you looking for a conservative or liberal computer?
Have you considered the Italian made Dacor Darwin or Mares M1? Or the Cressi-sub Archimede
made in Japan. They're also reviewed on that Rodale's site.


http://www.scubadiving.com/article/0...X19-15,00.html

Adam