Open Letter To Llanreath Divers

"david" wrote

> well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.
> I want my ashes made into the right type of concrete rock and placed in an
> artificial reef.
> is this also wrong ?

Is the artificial reef for the benefit of the environment or for the benefit
of those who place it, and your ashes, in the ocean?
Answer that and you have the answer to your question.

Do you suppose the environment benefits from a clock of lead with someone's
name on it?

Lee

>> well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.
>> I want my ashes made into the right type of concrete rock and placed in
>> an artificial reef.
>> is this also wrong ?
>
> Is the artificial reef for the benefit of the environment or for the
> benefit of those who place it, and your ashes, in the ocean?
> Answer that and you have the answer to your question.
>
> Do you suppose the environment benefits from a clock of lead with
> someone's name on it?
>
> Lee

http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en...Search& meta=

there are a few artificial reefs around. I choose how I live and after I die
a reef seems a better place than becoming worm food.

The block of lead bit is answered :-
>>well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.

funny how differnt things can cause a reaction.
dont you use a spear gun .....Lee

David

>> well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.
>> I want my ashes made into the right type of concrete rock and placed in
>> an artificial reef.
>> is this also wrong ?
>
> Is the artificial reef for the benefit of the environment or for the
> benefit of those who place it, and your ashes, in the ocean?
> Answer that and you have the answer to your question.
>
> Do you suppose the environment benefits from a clock of lead with
> someone's name on it?
>
> Lee

http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en...Search& meta=

there are a few artificial reefs around. I choose how I live and after I die
a reef seems a better place than becoming worm food.

The block of lead bit is answered :-
>>well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.

funny how differnt things can cause a reaction.
dont you use a spear gun .....Lee

David

>> well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.
>> I want my ashes made into the right type of concrete rock and placed in
>> an artificial reef.
>> is this also wrong ?
>
> Is the artificial reef for the benefit of the environment or for the
> benefit of those who place it, and your ashes, in the ocean?
> Answer that and you have the answer to your question.
>
> Do you suppose the environment benefits from a clock of lead with
> someone's name on it?
>
> Lee

http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en...Search& meta=

there are a few artificial reefs around. I choose how I live and after I die
a reef seems a better place than becoming worm food.

The block of lead bit is answered :-
>>well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.

funny how differnt things can cause a reaction.
dont you use a spear gun .....Lee

David

>> well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.
>> I want my ashes made into the right type of concrete rock and placed in
>> an artificial reef.
>> is this also wrong ?
>
> Is the artificial reef for the benefit of the environment or for the
> benefit of those who place it, and your ashes, in the ocean?
> Answer that and you have the answer to your question.
>
> Do you suppose the environment benefits from a clock of lead with
> someone's name on it?
>
> Lee

http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en...Search& meta=

there are a few artificial reefs around. I choose how I live and after I die
a reef seems a better place than becoming worm food.

The block of lead bit is answered :-
>>well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.

funny how differnt things can cause a reaction.
dont you use a spear gun .....Lee

David

>> well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.
>> I want my ashes made into the right type of concrete rock and placed in
>> an artificial reef.
>> is this also wrong ?
>
> Is the artificial reef for the benefit of the environment or for the
> benefit of those who place it, and your ashes, in the ocean?
> Answer that and you have the answer to your question.
>
> Do you suppose the environment benefits from a clock of lead with
> someone's name on it?
>
> Lee

http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en...Search& meta=

there are a few artificial reefs around. I choose how I live and after I die
a reef seems a better place than becoming worm food.

The block of lead bit is answered :-
>>well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.

funny how differnt things can cause a reaction.
dont you use a spear gun .....Lee

David

>> well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.
>> I want my ashes made into the right type of concrete rock and placed in
>> an artificial reef.
>> is this also wrong ?
>
> Is the artificial reef for the benefit of the environment or for the
> benefit of those who place it, and your ashes, in the ocean?
> Answer that and you have the answer to your question.
>
> Do you suppose the environment benefits from a clock of lead with
> someone's name on it?
>
> Lee

http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en...Search& meta=

there are a few artificial reefs around. I choose how I live and after I die
a reef seems a better place than becoming worm food.

The block of lead bit is answered :-
>>well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.

funny how differnt things can cause a reaction.
dont you use a spear gun .....Lee

David

>> well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.
>> I want my ashes made into the right type of concrete rock and placed in
>> an artificial reef.
>> is this also wrong ?
>
> Is the artificial reef for the benefit of the environment or for the
> benefit of those who place it, and your ashes, in the ocean?
> Answer that and you have the answer to your question.
>
> Do you suppose the environment benefits from a clock of lead with
> someone's name on it?
>
> Lee

http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en...Search& meta=

there are a few artificial reefs around. I choose how I live and after I die
a reef seems a better place than becoming worm food.

The block of lead bit is answered :-
>>well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.

funny how differnt things can cause a reaction.
dont you use a spear gun .....Lee

David

"david" wrote

> http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en...Search& meta=
>
> there are a few artificial reefs around. I choose how I live and after I
> die a reef seems a better place than becoming worm food.

No argument there. You asked the question. I simply pointed you to an
answer you already know. Some artificial reefs benefit the environment,
some don't. Whether yours does or doesn't is at the heart of the question
you asked.

> The block of lead bit is answered :-
>>>well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.

That's not an answer.

> funny how differnt things can cause a reaction.
> dont you use a spear gun .....Lee

Yep.
1. I didn't ask if it was right or wrong.
2. Use of my speargun has a very short term affect. Leaving stuff in the
ocean has a very long term affect.
3. My use of a speargun is, by a substantial margin, the least destructive
way for me to obtain food from the ocean. It's less destructive than any
form of commercial fishing and less destructive than any form of hook and
line fishing.

Lee

"david" wrote

> http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en...Search& meta=
>
> there are a few artificial reefs around. I choose how I live and after I
> die a reef seems a better place than becoming worm food.

No argument there. You asked the question. I simply pointed you to an
answer you already know. Some artificial reefs benefit the environment,
some don't. Whether yours does or doesn't is at the heart of the question
you asked.

> The block of lead bit is answered :-
>>>well I am not going to comment on Tony's marker.

That's not an answer.

> funny how differnt things can cause a reaction.
> dont you use a spear gun .....Lee

Yep.
1. I didn't ask if it was right or wrong.
2. Use of my speargun has a very short term affect. Leaving stuff in the
ocean has a very long term affect.
3. My use of a speargun is, by a substantial margin, the least destructive
way for me to obtain food from the ocean. It's less destructive than any
form of commercial fishing and less destructive than any form of hook and
line fishing.

Lee