Red Sea

Based on two live-aboard trips to the Coral Sea, first all the way out to Marion Reef
and a second trip further North to the Ribbons -- I would rate Australia/Coral Sea as
an "8"...Palau could easily be an "8" with those spectacular verticl drop-offs (some
undercut) in 3 feet of water with big corals hanging off them dropping into far off
depths. Ditto, the Galapagos gets an "8" as well as PNG. I think the Maldives (on a
good day where the coral hasn't been bleached out) deserves an "8" because of the way
you can almost be one-on-one with colorful reef fish (you can't do that anywhere else
that I know of).

I think the Philippines should get a "9" if there's anything left that resembles what
it used to be. I would give the Solomon's a "7" and Fiji, a "6". Those hanging
gardens in Sepidan should get a "7" although the time I was there the viz wasn't so
good. There are probably a few spots in Indonesia that still could be rated very
highly based on what I saw near Manado--haven't yet gotten to Wakatobi.

Dan Bracuk wrote:

> Daniel Kessler <dkessler@pop.cybernex.net> pounded away at his
> keyboard resulting in:
> :I dived it back in 1979...it was Sharm as my base and dived around that area.
> :It was very spectacular diving and having dived all over the world -- I give the
> :Red Sea -- on a scale of one to ten...it gets a 10.
> :
> :No other place gets a 10 from me....not the Coral Sea, Palau, Galapagos, the
> :Maldives, Indonesia, the Solomons, Fiji, PNG or even the Philippines. Well, the
> :Philippines, in terms of a greater variety of soft corals, did come close. I
> :wouldn't even dare mention anything in the Caribbean here which doesn't rate
> :above a "5" in my estimation.
> :
> :Why do I rate the Red Sea so highly...
>
> Actually, I am curious about how you rate the Coral Sea, Galapagos,
> Maldives, Indonesia, the Solomons, Fiji, PNG or even the Philippines.
>
> Dan Bracuk
> If we don't succeed, we run the risk of failure.
>
> ----== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com - Unlimited-Uncensored-Secure Usenet News==----
> http://www.newsfeeds.com The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World! 120,000+ Newsgroups
> ----= East and West-Coast Server Farms - Total Privacy via Encryption =----

In article <zSVFe.3036$d02.600492@news20.bellglobal.com>,
jspiers@sympatico.ca (Dp Pepper) wrote:

> *From:* "Dp Pepper" <jspiers@sympatico.ca>
> *Date:* Wed, 27 Jul 2005 20:43:13 -0400
>
> Has anyone dived the Red Sea?
> I am doing a week long liveabord in the southern area and am looking
> for any information about the area.
> Thanks
>
>

Done Sharm and Dahab on 6 or 7 different trips, but no liveaboard
experience in the Red Sea......but....

From the Uk you can now get regular flights down to Marsa Alam which i
think is considered "southern"..

I have had conversations with people that have done the "south", they mean
Sudan when they say south though, Sudan is or was a little dangerous i
think, but they say the diving down there was stunning, fantastic.....

Personly i would not take a "Northern" Red Sea liveaboard, the day boats
do most of what they do and the quality of hotels for your money is
terrific, or more bang for your buck........

Dave Morgan @ Work in the UK
Take out the "goes diving" bit....
Trip photos on line at www.morg.co.uk

In message <DbSdndVfU81JQHTfRVnygg@pipex.net>,
morgand@cix.compulink.co.uk writes
>In article <zSVFe.3036$d02.600492@news20.bellglobal.com>,
>jspiers@sympatico.ca (Dp Pepper) wrote:
>
>> *From:* "Dp Pepper" <jspiers@sympatico.ca>
>> *Date:* Wed, 27 Jul 2005 20:43:13 -0400
>>
>> Has anyone dived the Red Sea?
>> I am doing a week long liveabord in the southern area and am looking
>> for any information about the area.
>> Thanks
>>
>>
>
>Done Sharm and Dahab on 6 or 7 different trips, but no liveaboard
>experience in the Red Sea......but....
>
>From the Uk you can now get regular flights down to Marsa Alam which i
>think is considered "southern"..
>
>I have had conversations with people that have done the "south", they mean
>Sudan when they say south though, Sudan is or was a little dangerous i
>think, but they say the diving down there was stunning, fantastic.....
>
>Personly i would not take a "Northern" Red Sea liveaboard, the day boats
>do most of what they do and the quality of hotels for your money is
>terrific, or more bang for your buck........
>

I dont think you should discourage Northern Liveaboards on this basis.

Day boats take hours to get to Thistlegorm and Dunraven, and dont go to
Abu Nuhas, or Bluff Point.

In addition, there is nothing like being able to wake up and dive,
without the hours of hassle getting to the dive centre, then to the
boat, then to the site, even if it is only Tiran or Ras Mohammed.
(Only???)


--
Richard Faulkner

In article <Sfjv$iCPbg6CFwAp@estate.demon.co.uk>,
richard@estate.demon.co.uk (Richard Faulkner) wrote:

>
> I dont think you should discourage Northern Liveaboards on this basis.

I did qualify this with "personally"........but i would go on to say that
from the itineraries i have looked at for northern red sea liveaboards i
would not pay the extra money they want just to be at 2 or possibly 3
locations earlier than day boats.

> Day boats take hours to get to Thistlegorm and Dunraven, and dont go to
> Abu Nuhas, or Bluff Point.

I have done Thislegorm about 5 times, and a very good wreck dive it is
too, and can remember doing my safety stop in very clear water and looking
down on the whole ship thinking what a great dive, trying to remember the
whole dive for future reminiscences.
Your right of course it does take 4 hours plus from Sharm to Thislegorm
and a 04:30am start is not ideal, Dunraven however is ok from Sharm by day
boat, doing the Alternatives (pinnacles) and then Dunraven makes for a
good day out on the boat.
Personally i love the day boats from Sharm, the best dive boats i have
been on, big, sun deck, cooking for lunch, tea coffee, toilet etc i like
it because it is very relaxing...........although the day dive boats i
have been on in the Key's were big they didn't have sun deck or cooking
facilities as i recall.

> In addition, there is nothing like being able to wake up and dive,
> without the hours of hassle getting to the dive centre, then to the
> boat, then to the site, even if it is only Tiran or Ras Mohammed.
> (Only???)

Yes, "only"......some of the drifts i have been on at Woodhouse (Tiran)
Jackson etc have been so fast they have fooled the boats......yes,
surfacing to find no boat on more than one occasion, and Jolanda at Ras Mo
is my all time favourite dive site......coming up from the wreckage and
around the pinnacle is simply beautiful........

So i would not discourage northern liveaboards, but i would say look at
where they plan to dive and weigh up what you get over the day boats.

Dave Morgan @ Work in the UK
Take out the "goes diving" bit....
Trip photos on line at www.morg.co.uk